Racism and Christianity
I have a friend who describes herself as a “disinterested agnostic”. For several years I have tried to understand where she is coming in terms of her worldview. She is quite reluctant to talk to me about these things, which is perhaps understandable. She has been known to make some rather strong assertions regarding morality — for example, female circumcision, treatment of women in Afghanistan, and “white-flight” from schools that apparently have too many Muslims and indigenous attendees.
Recently she wrote about the latter on her blog, to which I responded:
I don’t personally like racism, and certainly feel emotionally for those who suffer at the hands of others, simply because their appearance is different due to minute differences in genetic coding.
However, at an intellectual level, I find it much more difficult to reject racism as evil. Indeed, to believe racism is actually evil, I would have to believe first that evil actually exists.
But how do I get to this realization?
If you are thinking: “what a moron — of course evil exists”, then convince me as to how you arrived that that conclusion.
Stating “this is evil” or “that is evil” is only making assertions, and even racists are good at making assertions. For an assertion to carry any weight, it requires a foundation, lest it just be merely an empty assertion.
So what do you think? Does she have a case, or is she being inconsistent with her worldview? Is she making baseless assertions? Or am i just being too hard on her?


























She is on the right track. Stating “this or that is evil” is being inconsistent with an atheistic worldview, as atheism cannot account for the existence of objective moral values. In an atheistic universe that is mighty strange furniture. But since she is agnostic and also realises that moral statements condemning actions such as racism become simply assertions in the absence of an ultimate foundation, all she needs to do is find a something to ground her basic moral intuitions. As the only firm foundation for morality is a theistic worldview with a morally perfect God it may be possible to help her along in her thinking. Perhaps present an axiological argument for the existence of God.
I recommend this article by Bill Craig;
(http://www.reasonablefaith.org/site/News2?page=NewsArticle&id=5175)